YES Network.com


Options, hamstrings and more

Michael Kay fields questions about the Yankees
05/03/2007 10:08 AM ET
By Michael Kay / Special to YESNetwork.com
post on facebook post on facebook fan comments Fan Comments print this pageprint this pagee-mail this pagee-mail this page

A-Rod has set himself up for a career season. (AP)

Editor's Note: The Yankees are now well into the 2007 season, and of the hundreds of YESNetwork.com users who e-mailed their questions, Michael Kay took the time this week to answered the best of the best. If you'd like to send a question for a future Q&A with Michael or any of the other YES Network broadcasters, click here.

Dear Michael,
Are all the muscle problems that have the Yankees have had a fluke or is there a problem with the conditioning program they are using?
-- DJ Kwasnicki, Guilderland Center, N.Y.

DJ,
You can never say for sure, but with the events of the past few days where the performance enhancement coach being let go it would seem like it was more than a coincidence.

_______________________

Michael,
With Melky Cabrera and Bobby Abreu both struggling at the plate, is there any chance Bernie Williams will be brought back to the Yankees? Also, do you think last year was a fluke year for Cabrera given his current struggles?
-- Marty, Scarsdale, N.Y.

Hi Marty,
If Bernie hasn't been contacted at this point I simply don't think it's going to happen. As for Cabrera, no, I do not think last year was a fluke but I do think he's putting way too much pressure on himself and it's adversely affecting his performance.

_______________________

Hello Michael,
I always believed that Derek Jeter is the best leadoff man on the Yankees. I think Johnny Damon when healthy is a good No. 2, with Jason Giambi at 3, A-Rod at 4, and Bobby Abreu at 5. Who do you think should be the leadoff man or who do you think the right man to lead off? Thanks.

-- Barbara, New York, NY

Hello Barbara,
I think Derek is the rare player that can hit anywhere in the lineup. He could even bat cleanup and he would have over 100 RBIs. That being said, I think Damon, when healthy, is a very good leadoff hitter and has a bit more speed than Derek. I would keep the two of them the way they are because that keeps the lefty-righty-lefty-righty-lefty balance at the top of the lineup rather than stacking lefties at Nos. 2-3. But I like your suggestion on moving Giambi to third, at least until Abreu breaks out of his slump.

_______________________

Michael,
With Phil Hughes gone for a while now, does that call into question the strength and conditioning program that the Yankee players are on, and what are some likely moves that Brian Cashman can make to shore up the pitching staff and the bench players?
-- Butch Williams, Valdosta, Ga.

Butch,
Refer back to answer number one for the first part of your question and as for the moves that Cashman can make, gee, I really don't know because no team has dropped out of it yet and is willing to trade a pitcher of substance.

_______________________

Hi Michael,
I realize the Yankees don't have the best starters in baseball (and their regulars have spent a lot of time on the DL), but I think Joe Torre really goes to the bullpen too much. At this rate we will need to send some of the relievers down to Columbus and bring up some others because they'll get burnt out by June. I think Joe needs to let the starters go deeper in the games sometimes, no matter the score. I think it would be better if you have to have your starters just eat up some innings even if they are getting hit a bit. Sometimes you need to lose the battle to win the war.

Ron Villone and Tanyon Sturtze are prime example of pitchers who were good, but were overused and then were gone. The same will happen with Proctor very soon.
-- Rick, Brooklyn, N.Y.

Hi Rick,
A lot of what you say has merit. The bullpen has been overused and I think Torre sometimes is a bit quick in yanking starters, but in fairness to the manager, most times he does not have a choice as these starters are getting hammered and have to be taken out to put out the fire and give the offense a chance to catch back up. That has already happened a couple of times in the two games where A-Rod has had walk-off home runs. I think Joe can do a bit better job of spreading the heavy workload among the relievers better than he has rather than seemingly using everybody for an inning every day.

_______________________

Dear Michael,
Why does Joe continue to run out a first baseman who just can not hit a lick? Why not try Josh Phelps against left-handers and Jason Giambi against right-handers? What is available on the market for first basemen?

-- Bob Hover, Rochester N.Y.

Dear Bob,
I would probably use Phelps a bit more although he is simply not a good defender. If you're going to go that route you might as well play Giambi at first and DH Cabrera. As for what's the market right now for first baseman, well, there is no market yet for anybody because it's too early. And if I may, I think the Yankee problems do not involve the slumping of Doug Mientkiewicz. They have enough offense, it's the pitching that's hurting them.

_______________________

Hi Michael,
Is the "fire" burned out? Against Tampa and Boston, Derek Jeter and A-Rod both got hit (Jeter twice and knocked out of a game), and four home runs in a ROW are hit by Boston. By the third (at least) batter, shouldn't he have been at least sitting in the dirt after the first pitch? Is seems that teams can "have their way" with the Yankees these days and nothing happens in return, and is this on the coaching staff, or the players (or captain) to do something about?

-- John Almekinder, Naples, N.Y.

Hi John,
In regards to what you're talking about, the fire was never lit. Throughout this entire dynastic run the Yankees have never protected their hitters. Remember the one game at the Stadium when Pedro Martinez literally sent Derek Jeter and Alfonso Soriano, the first two batters of the game, to the hospital and there was never retaliation. Never. Also David Ortiz and Manny Ramirez have owned the Yankees for years and they are never made to move their feet.

Who does this fall on? Well, if the pitchers aren't doing it themselves, and they should be, then the manager and coaches have to make it known that someone from the other team must go down. Not hit, just flipped, but there has to be a sign of toughness.

_______________________

Michael,
I said in the winter that the Yanks need pitching. Why didn't Brian Cashman consider this and why so stingy when they need a first baseman? And do you thing the injuries are from not enough working out?

-- Debbie Kister, Moorestown, N.J.

Debbie,
How can we rationally say the Yankees are stingy about anything when they have a $180 million payroll, more than any other team? And as for why there have been so many injuries, well, your guess is as good as mine but I don't think it has anything to do with the players being out of shape.

_______________________

Michael,
When and why did this obsession with pitch counts begin? You guys are now telling us in the first inning how many pitches have used. Back when Bob Gibson, Robin Roberts, Don Drysdale, and others were part of four-man rotations, pitching complete games, throwing 150 pitches, and 250-350 innings I don't remember hearing about pitch counts, or all the injuries that we see today with these pampered, coddled, five-inning, 90-pitch guys. The ludicrousness of it is that you give us pitch counts on knuckleball pitchers! Are you guys afraid they will wear out their fingertips?

-- Tony Moschetti, High Point, NC

Tony,
I agree with you. I think we give pitch counts too much on the air and I wish we didn't but since the game is governed this way in the dugout it does make sense to give the audience the number of pitches since when it reaches one hundred that is when the pitcher is probably going to be taken out. Back in the days you are talking about it was different because the pitchers were brought up differently and they were more used to throwing a lot of pitches. Now, the value of pitchers is through the roof and teams want to protect their investments and they baby the arms.

_______________________

Dear Mr. Kay,
Mike Mussina is 61 wins away from 300. Do you think there is a chance that he will achieve this? Do you think he could achieve this in Yankee pinstripes?

If A-Rod has this great season that everyone thinks he will have, do you think he is more or less prone to opting out of his contract?

Is a World Series title necessary for Joe Torre if he wants to manage next year? When he does, decide to retire is there a chance Joe Girardi will be the new manager and is there a chance Torre would manage somewhere else if he was not offered his job back?
-- Kaitlyn Brennan, Pearl River, New York

Hi Ms, Brennan,
I think Mussina has a shot at 300 but 61 is a lot and he is just signed for this year and next. Since he has been breaking down more and more frequently my gut feeling is he will not reach that number in pinstripes, but I'm not quite sure.

As for A-Rod, I've been trying to figure this out and I think the better the year he has the more likely he is to opt out. In fact, I think he either gets an extension from the Yankees, which they have said they won't do, or he opts out no matter what type of year he has.

And finally, I think Torre only has an opportunity to return if they win the championship. My gut tells me he wants to return but I don't think that happens unless he wins it all. Is there a possibility he manages somewhere else? Of course, but I think the only teams he would consider would be the Mets, Red Sox, Dodgers or Angels. And maybe one of the Chicago teams would appeal to him. Again, this is all guesswork and nothing anyone has told me. And if Torre is not here next year and think the manager would probably be Don Mattingly or Joe Girardi with Mattingly probably being the more likely to assume that role.

_______________________

Michael,
Do you think the Yankees can go, even until July 30 trading time, with "no offense" at first base, backup catcher and on the bench? Even though seven of the eight everyday positions are strong offensively, the rest of the roster seems incredibly weaker than at any time in recent memory.

-- Mark J. Bunim, Great Neck, N.Y.

Mark,
Yes I do. The problem is not their offense, it's their pitching. Geez, if their winning or losing hinges on the offense at first and backup catcher they are in trouble.

_______________________

Hi Michael,
Carl Pavano out, Jeff Karstens out, Phil Hughes out. Are there any options for Brian Cashman besides Roger Clemens? Did you hear some rumors about a possible trade for a starter?

-- Armin Kulovits, Austria

Hi Armin,
The only option, at this point, is Clemens. The Yankees have to tread water until the trade market loosens up while other teams fall out of it.

_______________________

Hi Michael!
First of all, just want to say that you are a great Yankee announcer and I really enjoy listening to you. I have two questions. One, I am a HUGE A-Rod supporter and I thought it was so unfair the way he was treated last year. Do you think that he can carry this amazing April into the rest of the year and maybe even into the postseason?

Two, I have always heard that you were or are a Yankees fan. During the few games that you don't announce, are you at home cheering the Yankees on? Thanks for your time!
-- Ally, Byram, N.J

Hi Ally,
I do believe that A-Rod is going to have a great year although I doubt he can keep this pace the entire season because his total numbers would then be superhuman.

Also, I grew up in the Bronx and was the biggest Yankees fan. In fact, there were years where I did not miss a game on TV or radio the entire season. As for the days I am off, I have to honestly say I usually do not watch the entire games but rather check in periodically to find out what is going on.

Thanks, everyone!

post on facebook post on facebook fan comments Fan Comments print this pageprint this pagee-mail this pagee-mail this page
Write a Comment! Post a Comment
-

Today on YESNetwork.com

  • Triple Play Trivia

    Triple Play Trivia

    Test your knowledge of new Yankee Randy Winn with Yankees Triple Play Trivia.

  • Follow us on Twitter

    Follow us on Twitter

    @YESNetwork keeps you up to date on all the latest Yankees news. Follow us now.

  • River Avenue Blues

    River Avenue Blues

    Part of the YESNetwork.com blogging network, River Avenue Blues provides ongoing Yankees commentary.

YES Network Poll

YES Network Photos